Reviews

My wife and I have been looking for a good bakery. Sick of Tops and Wegmans bakery. Due to traffic on 290, we took Harlem. We drove by Wheatberry and turned around and stopped in. What a awesome place. The baked goods looked fresh and homemade. They even have cupcakes which are hide to find. We tried their cookies, danish and eclairs. The Danish was great and fresh. The eclair was the best I ever had. Its my favorite baked product. The cookies were good. The cakes and bread looked good. Can't wait to try those.

Amazing pastries! Everything is delicious!

If there were an Olympic event for bread, Scott would be standing on the podium while the rest of the world argued in the parking lot. Scott is not just a baker. He's not just a pastry wizard. He is the main character of Wheatberry Bake Shop and the undisputed World's Greatest Bread Baker. Week after week, walking into that shop and seeing his smile while he hands over fresh-baked bread, cookies, and pastries is one of the highlights of our weekends. It's not an errand. It's an event. And here's the real flex: We NEVER send thank-you cards to restaurants. Ever. But we actually sent one to Scott. That's how much this place (and this person) means to us. Our "two-minute" conversations never feel rushed, never feel forced. Scott is warm, funny, welcoming, and just genuinely one of those rare humans who makes your day better just by being in it. You come for the bread. You stay for the soul. Also yes, we bought him a "Bread Father" t-shirt. And yes, he earned it. We are lifelong customers and we're not accepting substitutions. It's Scott. Always Scott. This is not a bakery review... this is a loyalty pledge.
Wheatberry isn't just where you buy bread. It's where you go to remember the world still makes things with heart.

Many options including vegetarian. We had almond ring, peach turnover and chocolate walnut brownies. All of high quality ingredients,craft and taste.

Will 100% reccomend Wheatberry for every and any occasion! From their cakes to their baked goods.. to the owners and staff, everything is amazing!!!

The most delicious almond ring on the planet! It was worth every calorie

Very welcoming! The bread, coffee cake, and cupcake were so delicious!

This was my first time into the Wheatberry Bake Shop, and it certainly won't be my last! The service was personable and outstanding! Everything was so delicious looking, that I didn't know what to choose! I ended up going with an array of cupcakes and an eclair because it was recommended. I am currently having the eclair with my morning coffee, and the recommendation was warranted! (10/10) I can't wait to try the cupcakes with my fiancé tonight! The only downfall of Wheatberry is that I live down the street and will be going too often!

We ordered my son's first birthday cake from Wheatberry & it was phenomenal! The cake was so delicious & the customer service was amazing. Everyone was so friendly and really helped my vision come to life from start to finish!

The DIY Santa experience was awesome and the kids had an excellent time with a more low key Santa experience. The food looks amazing and we are absolutely going to come back again. Thank you for keeping the Christmas magic for our children!

The kindness of the staff was unmatched. I felt like more than a customer. The top notch bakery items are an added bonus! Love the vegan options as well. Can't recommend this bakery enough.

Super friendly staff, AMAZING baked goods!

Awesome place to get a treat for myself or to enjoy at an event!!!

Wheatberry did an amazing job for our wedding cakes. We couldn't be happier with the outcome. They accommodated my vegan diet and make a cutting cake for us that was entirely vegan and decorated exactly how we wanted. They also made a non-vegan sheet cake for the rest of our guests. All of our guests raved about how great the cake was and many people asked us for the name of the bakery it was definitely a big hit. The staff was also great to work with, they helped us pick dessert options for everyone when we came in for our cake tasting and also coordinated drop of with our venue so there was nothing to stress about day of.

I'm going by what my brother told me about the atmosphere, as he picked up my order, a very special coconut lime birthday cake and a strawberry pie. Haven't tried the pie yet--it's a gift for someone--but it looks beautiful and substantial. Much to my surprise it has a top crust, which, to me, should make it extra delicious. Everyone loved the cake and no one said "Ew, this must be gluten free and vegan" (which it is). Every morsel served was devoured. A great experience. So happy to have someone else to make delicious treats suitable for all of us.

Great family bakery with many vegan options

Love this Bakery!

Stoped in on lunch and got a vegan cupcake, I can never enjoy the frosting on a cupcake because it upsets my stomach. WOW it was so good and no tummy ache! Thanks for the sweet treat on a rough day!

Love this place. They did a vegan birthday cake for my boyfriend. The cake is beautiful and it was so so delicious!! Can't wait to be back for more stuff. Thanks everyone at Wheatberry!!!

Had a cake from there it was fantastic! Everyone at the party loved it, I would highly recommend wheatberrys to everyone.ty for your friendly service and azong cake.

I couldn't get home fast enough to try the "GT" (Garlic Tuscan) loaf... it was absolutely amazing. Scott was phenemonal in helping me pick out some vegan options, very friendly and wonderful. Looking forward to coming back to try the sandwiches!

Lindsay did a magnificent and amazing job for my husband's 70th birthday cake, exactly the flavors we wanted with a spectacular design on top. No one better in the area!!

Oh such delicious goodies and beautiful cakes!!! I always have to stop in when I am in their neighborhood.

Awesome place. Most beautiful cupcakes

Exceptional bakery experience! From the moment I stepped in, the aroma of freshly baked goods was enchanting. The array of pastries, bread, and cakes was not only visually stunning but also a testament to the craftsmanship of the bakers. Each bite was a burst of flavor, showcasing the use of high-quality ingredients. The staff's warmth and attentiveness added to the overall delightful atmosphere. A must-visit for anyone seeking a delectable journey through the world of baked delights!

When I walked into this bakery I was instantly in bakery heaven. The smell of the place was amazing! Being a cookie cake pastry conissour I have to say everything I tried was absolutely delicious and the owner was so very friendly and helpful. I ordered the almond bear claw, chocolate topped cream puff, white chocolate raspberry cupcake, mocha shortbread cookies, and the Cinnamon Brioche bread which we made French toast with! All of it phenomenal!!!

Excellent bakery, warm and friendly atmosphere. Their signature "Wheatberry" bread has become a regular in our home. Scott makes the most wonderful bear claws packed with a delicious almond filling. His eclairs are the best European choux pastry, creamy custard filling and topped with a chocolate ganache; not too sweet, just perfect.

The people are so sweet. I coming here again. Their sweets are really amazing. I feel at home.

She did a FANTASTIC job! My mother in law surprised us by ordering a wedding cake from her and it could not have been better!
The colors are perfect, design was perfect, taste was amazing!
I am dairy free and the rest of the family is not and she made us a two tier wedding cake the top being vegan and the bottom regular! They were both SO good. I am so so so grateful.
She even delivered it to their home for us! If I could give 10 stars I would!!!

Had an excellent wedding cake made, was delivery right to my house and tasted amazing!!!!